Do I Need to Hire a Long-Term Disability Lawyer?

Hire a long-term disability attorney to avoid missteps that could cost you your LTD benefits.

By , J.D. University of Missouri School of Law
Updated 2/28/2024

If you have long-term disability (LTD) insurance and become unable to work, you should consider hiring an experienced LTD attorney as soon as possible to maximize your chances of success. Filing a long-term disability claim, especially when you have employer-provided group coverage, is a process fraught with danger for the unrepresented disability applicant. A single missed deadline, improperly completed form, or wrongly uttered word to a claims adjuster can place your long-term disability benefits in jeopardy.

What Can a Long-Term Disability Attorney Do for Me?

Employer-provided group long-term disability insurance is governed by ERISA, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, a federal law that provides for very specific procedures and time limits for filing LTD claims. A lawyer experienced with long-term disability claims will know how to abide by the ERISA rules and help you succeed, especially in the following areas.

Preparing Your LTD Claims File for a Lawsuit

One provision that frequently catches applicants by surprise is that, in a lawsuit against your insurer, you're generally prohibited from introducing new evidence. The federal judge, with very limited exceptions, decides your case based on what's in your claims file with the insurance company (called the "administrative record").

An experienced ERISA lawyer will try to "stack the administrative record" with medical, vocational, and other favorable evidence before you "exhaust" your internal appeals—that is, you complete your appeal within the insurance company. (Learn more about the LTD appeal process here.)

Your attorney will make sure that your claim file contains all your relevant medical evidence and will work with your physicians to obtain supportive opinions about your work-related limitations. Knowing the right questions to ask your doctors, rather than relying on the often biased paperwork provided by your insurance company, can be one of your attorney's most valuable contributions.

Hiring Your Own Vocational Expert

Depending on whether you have an "own occupation" or "any occupation" disability policy, your attorney may ask a vocational expert to testify about the requirements of your position or the overall labor market. It is rarely a good idea to rely on the testimony of supposedly "independent" vocational experts hired by your LTD carrier.

Acting as Your Legal Representative

In addition to obtaining persuasive evidence of your disability, your attorney will also interact with the LTD carrier or plan administrator on your behalf, file your initial application and appeals in a timely manner, conduct settlement negotiations, and if necessary, bring a lawsuit in federal court.

When Should I Hire a Long-Term Disability Attorney?

It's never too early to hire an attorney to represent you in your long-term disability case. As soon as you become unable to work, contact an LTD attorney to discuss how you should proceed. An attorney will generally give you a free consultation or case evaluation over the phone or in person, so there's nothing to lose.

While many workers filing for LTD benefits wait until their claim has been initially denied to talk to an attorney, hiring a lawyer to help with your initial application can protect your interests, and it's highly recommended. Here are some examples of common mistakes made by unrepresented workers who are trying to file an LTD claim on their own:

  • Quitting work and then trying to file for disability benefits. Most employer-provided LTD policies state that coverage ends immediately when the employment relationship has terminated.
  • Transitioning to a less demanding or lower-paying position. Employees who try to make good-faith efforts to continue working despite their impairments may end up unintentionally harming a potential LTD case. Working at a less strenuous occupation can make an "own occupation" claim harder to win, while taking a lower-paying job could decrease your future monthly LTD amount.
  • Making mistakes on the application for benefits. Insurance companies frequently design their paperwork to mislead applicants into answering in a way that could lead to a denial. A disability attorney can alert you to the tricks and traps commonly used by insurers to deny benefits.

If you've already filed your initial application and have been denied, it's critical to hire an attorney to help with your administrative appeals. Both group and individual LTD policies contain strict timelines, often 180 days, to appeal a denial, so don't delay.

How Much Will an LTD Attorney Cost Me?

Most disability attorneys handle LTD cases on a contingency fee basis, typically charging between 25% and 40% of the past-due benefits that the insurance company owes you. Under a contingency arrangement, you don't owe the lawyer a fee unless you win your case.

Your attorney will likely front the money for the costs of litigation, including depositions, travel expenses, medical records, and postage, but require you to reimburse the costs of these expenses, sometimes even if you lose your case. Be sure to ask about:

  • whether you'll have to pay for litigation-related expenses
  • how much you should expect to pay, and
  • whether you'll be billed even if your claim is unsuccessful.

Also, be aware that some LTD attorneys charge a percentage of your past-due benefits and your future benefits as well. Feel free to try to negotiate this term, and if your attorney insists, consider taking your business to an LTD attorney who will accept a one-time payment from your back benefits. For more information, see our article on how much an LTD lawyer costs.

Finding a Long-Term Disability Lawyer

It's essential that you find an attorney with experience handling long-term disability cases rather than a general practitioner who will have to learn ERISA law on the fly. LTD cases are too complex and too important to be handled by a lawyer who doesn't specialize in disability law.

Talk to a Lawyer

Need a lawyer? Start here.

How it Works

  1. Briefly tell us about your case
  2. Provide your contact information
  3. Choose attorneys to contact you
Make the Most of Your Claim

Get the compensation you deserve.

We've helped 225 clients find attorneys today.

How It Works

  1. Briefly tell us about your case
  2. Provide your contact information
  3. Choose attorneys to contact you