Should I Tell a Debt Collector to Stop Contacting Me?

The federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) gives you the right to force a debt collector to stop communicating with you. If you send a cease and desist letter to a debt collector, the collector must stop contacting you except to tell you that:

• it’s ending communications, or
• it may (or will) sue you or use another legal remedy to collect the debt. (15 U.S.C. § 1692c).

But while telling a debt collector to stop contacting you might provide some temporary relief, it can also keep you in the dark about what the debt collector is doing and increase the chance that the debt collector will sue you.

Benefits of Telling a Debt Collector to Stop Contacting You

The benefit of sending a debt collector a cease and desist letter is that they'll stop contacting you. If a collector continues to contact you, other than for the reasons listed above, you can sue for a violation of the FDCPA and ask for money damages.

Drawbacks of Telling a Debt Collector to Stop Contacting You

Many consumer advocates advise against sending a cease and desist letter unless the debt collector is harassing you or causing significant stress in your life. Here are some drawbacks to telling a debt collector to stop communicating with you.

Lack of Information

Telling a debt collector not to contact you doesn’t eliminate the underlying debt. Even if the debt collector can’t contact you, it can still take legal steps to collect the debt, like filing a lawsuit. By stopping all communications with the collector, you limit the amount of information you get regarding the debt and what the debt collector is doing.

Increased Chance of Collection Lawsuits

When you force a debt collector to stop contacting you, the debt collector often has no choice but to either:

• sell the debt to a different collector, or
• sue you in court to collect the debt.

For this reason, sending a cease and desist letter might increase the likelihood that the debt collector will file a lawsuit against you to enforce the debt. If you don’t defend the lawsuit, the debt collector can obtain a default judgment (an automatic win). Then, if you have enough income or property, it might be able to garnish your wages or attach (seize) your assets.

When It Might Be a Good Idea to Send a Cease and Desist Letter

In some cases, it might make sense to tell a debt collector to stop contacting you.

The Debt Collector Is Harassing You

The FDCPA prohibits debt collectors from calling you repeatedly, using profane language, making threats, or otherwise harassing you. If a debt collector is constantly calling you and causing you stress, sending a cease and desist letter can stop the collector from harassing you.

Keep in mind, though, if the debt collector is engaging in these behaviors, you have several other options, including:

• suing the collector in state court or small claims court
• reporting the collector to a government agency
• reporting the collector to your state attorney general, and
• using FDCPA violations as leverage in debt settlement negotiations.

The Statute of Limitations Has Expired

Once you default on a debt, the creditor has a specific amount of time to file a lawsuit against you to collect on it. This time limit is called the "statute of limitations." In most cases, state law determines the length of the statute of limitations. When the statute of limitations expires, the creditor can’t sue you to collect the debt.

But keep in mind that some actions, such as making a partial payment or a promise to pay, might reset the statute of limitations clock. Also, even if the statute of limitations expires, you still owe the debt. So, a debt collector can still contact you to collect the debt even if it can’t sue you.

If you know for sure that the statute of limitations has expired, it might make sense to send a cease and desist letter to stop the collection calls.

It’s Not Your Debt

If a debt collector contacts you about a debt that you’re sure you don’t owe, sending a cease and desist letter can stop the collector from calling you again. But because creditors routinely sell their debts to different debt collectors, it can be hard to know for sure whether you owe the debt.

Under the FDCPA, you have a right to dispute the debt and request verification from the debt collector within 30 days after you first receive notice of the obligation. Until the debt collector sends you proof that you owe the debt, it must stop its collection efforts. It's usually a good idea to ask the collector to verify the debt before sending a cease and desist letter.

Talk to an Attorney

If you need help dealing with an aggressive debt collector, figuring out what option is best for handling your debts, negotiating a settlement, or responding to a lawsuit for nonpayment of a debt, consider consulting with a lawyer. Once you’ve hired a lawyer, under the FDCPA, a collector must talk to your attorney only—not you—unless you give permission to contact you or your lawyer doesn’t respond to the collection agency's communications.