Federal and state anti-discrimination laws limit what you can say and do in the tenant selection process. When choosing tenants, keep in mind the following best practices.
Today you can easily run a credit check for a minimal fee. Also, you can and should call the tenant's references, especially former landlords. You should also verify an applicant's employment, income, and bank account information. Be consistent in your screening. Make it your policy, for example, to always require credit reports; don't just get a credit report for a single parent or people of a particular nationality.
You are legally free to choose among prospective tenants as long as your decisions are based on legitimate business criteria. Don't make choices based on personal reasons. You are entitled to reject applicants with bad credit histories, income that you reasonably regard as insufficient to pay the rent, or past behavior—such as property damage or consistent late rent payments—that makes someone a bad risk. It goes without saying that you may legally refuse to rent to someone who can't come up with the security deposit or meet some other condition of the tenancy.
Fair housing laws specify clearly illegal reasons to refuse to rent to a tenant. The Federal Fair Housing Acts (42 U.S. Code § §3601-3619, 3631) prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, religion, national origin, gender, age, familial status, physical or mental disability (including recovering alcoholics and people with a past drug addiction). Many states and cities also prohibit discrimination based on marital status or sexual orientation.
Anybody who deals with prospective tenants must follow fair housing laws. This includes owners, landlords, managers and real estate agents, and all of their employees. As the property owner, you may be held legally responsible for your employees' discriminatory statements or conduct, including sexual harassment.
Consistency is crucial when dealing with prospective tenants. If you don't treat all tenants more or less equally—for example, if you arbitrarily set tougher standards when renting to members of a racial minority—you are violating federal laws and opening yourself up to lawsuits. And if you give one person a break (such as lowering the security deposit for a single mother but not for other tenants), you'll likewise risk a charge of discrimination from other tenants.
There's a lot more to finding and screening good tenants. For information on creating rental applications, performing credit and criminal background checks, and evaluating and rejecting tenants, see Every Landlord's Guide to Finding Great Tenants, by Janet Portman (Nolo). This book includes 40 forms (available for download on Nolo.com), including a rental application, a legal residency form, and a rejection letter, along with two consent forms: one for contacting references and performing a credit check, the other for performing a criminal and background check.
Need a lawyer? Start here.