Sometimes Chapter 13 debtors need or want to convert their bankruptcy case from a Chapter 13 to a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. And sometimes the bankruptcy court will force you to convert from Chapter 13 to Chapter 7 – this is often called a "forced conversion."
The reasons for conversions vary. For the most part, if you
are instigating the conversion, you have a right to convert your case. But that
doesn’t always mean you’ll qualify for Chapter 7 relief.
Learn when you might want to convert from Chapter 13 to 7,
when the court might force you to do so, and whether you will face any
eligibility issues.
Reasons to Convert from Chapter 13 to Chapter 7
You might want to convert from Chapter 13 to Chapter 7
because:
- your financial circumstances have changed and
you can no longer make the Chapter 13 plan payments, or
- you filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy primarily to
keep certain property, and you decide you no longer want to keep that property
(for example, your home or an expensive musical instrument).
When the Court Might Force You to Convert
The bankruptcy court can order you to convert your case to
Chapter 7 only “for cause.” Examples of what constitutes cause for forced
conversion include:
- failure to file a Chapter 13 plan on time
- failure to make Chapter 13 plan payments, or
- unreasonable delay that causes harm to your
creditors.
Are You Allowed to Convert?
You have a right to convert your Chapter 13 bankruptcy
case to a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case at any time, with one restriction. You cannot
convert to Chapter 7 if you have received a Chapter 7 discharge within the
previous eight years.
Will You Qualify for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Relief?
However, even though you can convert your Chapter 13
bankruptcy to Chapter 7, in order to proceed with the Chapter 7 you must be
eligible for Chapter 7 relief. There are a few eligibility requirements for
filing for Chapter 7; the biggest one is that you must pass the means test.
What is the means test? The means test looks at your income and expenses and essentially
determines whether you can pay some of your debts through a Chapter 13 plan. If
you can, you don’t qualify for Chapter 7. (To learn more about the means test,
see our Chapter
7 Eligibility & the Means Test area.)
Does the means test
apply to converted cases? Whether you must pass the means test when you
convert your Chapter 13 case to a Chapter 7 case is an open question. Some
courts have ruled that in converted cases, the debtor still must pass the means
test in order to be eligible for Chapter 7 relief. See e.g. In re Chapman, 447 B.R. 250 (B.A.P. 8th
Cir. 2011); In re Lassiter, 2011 WL
2039363 (Bankr. E.D. Va. 2011); In re
Phillips, 417 B.R. 30 (Bankr. S.D. Ohio 2009). Other courts, however, have
ruled that the means test doesn’t apply to Chapter 7 cases that have been
converted from Chapter 13. See e.g. In re
Guarin, 2009 WL 4500476 (Bankr. D. Mass. 2009); In re Willis, 408 B.R. 803 (Bankr. W.D. Missouri 2009); In re Dudley, 405 B.R. 790 (Bankr. W.D.
Va. 2009).
Will you pass the
means test? What if you originally filed for Chapter 13 because you
couldn’t pass the means test? If your financial circumstances have changed, you
may pass the means test now. Take it again. (For a handy online means test
calculator, use Nolo’s
Bankruptcy Means Test Calculator.)
Filing Procedures for Converted Cases
Here’s what happens with your paperwork and the process if
you convert your case.
The petition and
schedules. In most courts, the bankruptcy petition and forms that you filed
for your Chapter 13 case become a part of your converted Chapter 7 case.
However, you may have to amend some of the forms to list any debts you incurred
after filing your Chapter 13 case (these can be discharged in your Chapter 7
case if they are otherwise dischargeable). And you’ll have to file another
form, the Statement of Intention
(this form tells the court what you plan to do with your secured debts.) A few
courts require you to file a new set of schedules, even if nothing has changed.
Proofs of Claims. The
creditors’ Proofs of Claims, if
already filed, carry over to your Chapter 7 case.
The creditors’
meeting. You must attend another meeting of creditors, even if one was
already held in your Chapter 13 case.
Exemptions. Some
courts determine your exemptions as of the date you filed for Chapter 13
bankruptcy, while other courts determine them as of the date you convert to
Chapter 7. (For more on exemptions, see
our Bankruptcy
Exemptions area.)