Do police officers have more rights to search my car if it's near a U.S. border?
Because the government has a unique interest in policing its borders at and around border crossings, and because people have a lower reasonable expectation of privacy at such places, police officers can search cars and their occupants even if they have no reason to be suspicious. Essentially, neither citizens nor noncitizens have Fourth Amendment rights in these situations, with few exceptions (personal searches, such as strip-searches and body-cavity searches, may require a warrant).
Customs or immigration officials may conduct warrantless searches without probable cause not only at borders, but at their "functional equivalents," such as international airports. Essentially, neither citizens nor noncitizens have Fourth Amendment rights in these situations.
Border officials may stop motorists at fixed checkpoints that are reasonably located relative to the border, to question motorists even in the absence of reasonable suspicion of a crime, let alone probable cause. (U.S. v. Martinez-Fuerte, U.S. Supreme Court, 1976.) The right to search in the absence of suspicion allows police to dismantle a car, and even extends to searching a vehicle’s gas tank (U.S. v. Flores-Montano, U.S. Sup. Ct. 2004).
Police using roving patrols need a reasonable suspicion that crime is afoot before they can stop a car, unlike the broader right to stop and search at the border. However, the fact that occupants appear to be Hispanic will not, by itself, justify a roving patrol stop. (U.S. v. Brignoni-Ponce, U.S. Supreme Court, 2004.) Patrols may not search a car without a warrant unless an exception to the warrant requirement applies, such as when occupants give consent.
Whether the stop and search in your case was valid will depend on how appellate courts in your state have decided in cases involving facts such as yours. You'll need the help of an experienced criminal defense attorney to know where you case falls within the "valid-not valid" spectrum of cases.
by: Janet Portman, Attorney
Proof & Defenses in Criminal Cases
Getting a Lawyer for your Criminal Case
Steps in a Criminal Defense Case
Arraignment: Your First Court Appearance
Plea Bargains (Deals) in a Criminal Case
Legal Elements of Common Crimes
Expungement & Criminal Records
Should I just plead guilty and avoid a trial?
Is the public defender a real lawyer?
Can I change defense lawyers after I've hired one?
How long after arrest do I find out what the charges are?
Does it matter whether a suspect is given the Miranda warning?
Copyright © 2014 Nolo ® |
Security & Privacy |
Disclaimer -- Legal information is not legal advice