Homicide: Murder and Manslaughter
The crimes of murder and manslaughter explained, with real-world examples.
Homicide is a legal term for any killing of a human being by another human being. Homicide itself is not necessarily a crime–some homicides are legal, such as a justifiable killing of a suspect by the police or a killing in self-defense–but unlawful homicides are classified as crimes like murder and manslaughter.
This article explains the important but often subtle distinctions between murder and manslaughter, and the different variations of both crimes. Keep in mind that in real-world criminal cases, a jury’s choice between murder and manslaughter may depend less on abstract legal rules than on a judgment about just how morally blameworthy a defendant is.
What Is the Legal Definition of Murder?
Under the common law (law originating from custom and court decisions rather than statutes), murder was an intentional killing that was:
- unlawful (in other words, not legally justified), and
- committed with "malice aforethought."
Malice aforethought doesn't mean that a killer has to have acted out of spite or hate. It exists if a defendant intends to kill someone without legal justification or excuse. In addition, in most states, malice aforethought isn't limited to intentional killings. It can also exist if the killer:
- intentionally inflicts serious bodily harm that causes the victim's death, or
- behaves in a way that shows extreme, reckless disregard for life and results in the victim's death.
In today’s society, murder is defined by statute, rather than common law. And, though contemporary statutes emanate from common law, one has to look to these statutes for important distinctions. Like the difference between first and second degree murder.
First Degree Murder vs. Second Degree Murder
Even within the universe of those who kill with malice aforethought, the law regards some as more dangerous and morally blameworthy than others; first degree murder applies to these defendants. Killings involving malice that don't amount to first degree murder tend to constitute second degree murder.
The rules vary somewhat from state to state as to what circumstances make an intentional killing first degree murder, but the following circumstances commonly do so:
The killing is deliberate and premeditated. In other words, the killer has formed the intent to kill and has had time, however brief, to reflect on the matter. An obvious example of premeditation is a wife going to the store, buying a lethal dose of rat poison, and putting it in her husband's tea. (For more detail, see What is premeditated and deliberate conduct?)
The killing occurs during the course of a dangerous felony. This crime is often known as felony murder. A felon can be guilty of murder if a death occurs during the course of a dangerous felony, even if the felon is not the killer. In most states, the death must be a foreseeable result of the initial felony. For example, assume that Aaron commits arson by setting a house on fire. Chris, a firefighter, dies while attempting to douse the burning building. Here, Aaron would be guilty of felony murder because a death occurred in the course of a dangerous felony, and the death was a foreseeable result of the defendant’s actions. (Aaron might also be guilty of old-fashioned murder on the theory that he acted with malice aforethought.)
In most states, a defendant isn’t liable for the death of his or her accomplice if the defendant didn’t directly cause it. Suppose, for example, that Bill and Janice burglarize a house. As they attempt to flee with the loot, a police officer shoots and kills Janice. Bill would not be guilty of first degree murder, even though a death occurred in the course of a dangerous felony. (Com. v. Redline, 391 Pa. 486, 508 (1958).)
For much more on the nuances of this area of law, see Felony Murder.
The killer uses an explosive device such as a bomb. In California, for example, the statute defining first degree murder specifies several ways in which the crime can occur. In part, it states, “All murder which is perpetrated by means of a destructive device or explosive … or by any other kind of willful, deliberate, and premeditated killing … is murder of the first degree.” (Cal. Penal Code § 189.)
Punishment for Murder
Many states have mandatory minimum sentences for murder. The mandatory minimum for first degree murder is almost always higher than that for second degree murder. Defendants convicted of first degree murder can also be eligible for the ultimate penalty: death. Many states and the federal government still have the death penalty. In other states, the maximum penalty is life in prison without the possibility of parole (LWOP).Defendants convicted of second degree murder are often sentenced to a term of years rather than life in prison and are almost always eligible for parole.
1 | 2