If you are legally married to your same-sex partner (that is, you
married in a state, country, or province that recognizes same-sex marriage), can
you file a joint bankruptcy petition? Until recently, the answer was no. But
today, in some jurisdictions you can file a joint petition with your same-sex
spouse.
Joint Bankruptcy Petitions
Bankruptcy law allows married couples to file one bankruptcy
petition together – called a joint bankruptcy petition. For most couples,
filing a joint bankruptcy is more advantageous than filing an individual
bankruptcy, but not always. (To learn more about joint bankruptcy and its pros
and cons, see our Filing Considerations for Married Couples area.)
Special Issues for Same-Sex Married Couples
Although many of the pros and cons of filing a joint
petition for different-sex married couples apply to same-sex married couples, keep
in mind that some issues that arise in bankruptcy may be different. For
example, federal law treats the income of same-sex married couples as that of
“roommates” – which means you could file an individual Chapter 7 bankruptcy and
not have to count your spouse’s income for purposes of the means test. This
could be advantage if your spouse’s income would cause you to fail the means
test. (To learn more about the means test, see our Means
Test and Other Chapter 7 Eligibility Issues area.)
Same-Sex Couples and Joint Bankruptcy
Although the bankruptcy code never defines a married couple
as two spouses of different genders, until recently, bankruptcy courts would
not allow same-sex married couples to file joint bankruptcy petitions. This was
in large part because of the federal Defense of Marriage Act or DOMA (1 U.S.C.
§ 7 and 28 U.S.C. § 1738C) which states that the federal government does not
recognize same-sex marriage and that states may disregard such marriages
performed in other states.
Recently, however, some bankruptcy courts have allowed
same-sex married couples to file joint bankruptcy petitions. For example, in one
case, a same-sex couple that legally married in California in 2008 filed a
joint Chapter 13 bankruptcy petition. The U.S. Trustee initially opposed the
petition on the grounds that the couple was not “married” under federal law. In
June 2011, the bankruptcy court (in an opinion, signed by 20 of the 24
bankruptcy judges in the Central District of California), ruled that the couple
could pursue the joint Chapter 13 bankruptcy. (In re: Balas and Morales, 449 B.R. 567 (C.D.Cal. 2011).) In rendering its opinion, the court declared
that DOMA was unconstitutional.
Several weeks later, on July 6, 2011, the U.S. Department of
Justice stated that it would no longer oppose joint bankruptcy petitions filed
by same-sex married couples. In theory, this would mean that the U.S. Trustee
for the different bankruptcy jurisdictions would not oppose such petitions.
What happens in practice, however, still remains to be seen.
The Evolving Law: Consult With a Local Bankruptcy Attorney
Despite the Justice Department’s announcement and several
courts’ allowance of joint petitions filed by same-sex married couples, it’s
still not clear how different courts and districts will treat joint petitions
filed by same-sex married couples. Some U.S. Trustee’s may continue to oppose
such petitions, and there’s nothing preventing creditors from raising an
objection as well.