If a creditor is attempting to garnish your wages, you may be able to challenge the garnishment by raising an objection. The procedures you need to follow to object to a wage garnishment depend on the type of debt that the creditor is trying to collect from you, as well as the laws of your state. This article explains the basic ways you can object to a wage garnishment.
(To learn what a wage garnishment is, and reasons you may be able to object, and to find state wage garnishment limits, visit Nolo's Wage Garnishment topic area.)
Wage Garnishments by Judgment Creditors
If you owe a creditor on a debt like a loan, hospital bill, or credit card, it cannot automatically garnish your wages. Instead, it must first sue you and get a judgment against you from a court. Once that happens, then the judgment creditor must file papers with the court to start the garnishment process.
Usually, you have the right to written notice and a hearing before your employer starts holding back some of your wages to pay your judgment creditor. Typically, that notice is in the form of a Notice of Garnishment of Personal Earnings or similar document that the court sends you. Once you have received this notice that your wages are about to be garnished, you have to act quickly. You have a limited amount of time, which can range from 30 days to just five business days, to object before the garnishments begin.
Filing a Written Objection to the Wage Garnishment
The process for objecting to a garnishment usually begins with preparing and filing paperwork. The garnishment documents that you received from the court should contain instructions on what you must do to object to the garnishment. Those instructions should include:
the deadline for filing the objection
whether that objection must be in writing
whether you must use a court-provided form or draft your own written objection
the type of information your written objection should contain
where you should file the objection
whether you must also serve a copy of your objection on the judgment creditor and other parties, and
the date, time and location of any hearing that the court will hold to consider your objection.
If the garnishment papers you received do not contain this information, immediately contact the clerk of the court that issued the garnishment documents to find out this information.
Usually, a form will be included with the garnishment notice that you can use to write your objection and request a hearing. If it is not, you should ask for one from the clerk of the court that sent you the garnishment notice. If the court does not have a form, you should write out your objection to the best that you are able and file it on time.
For step-by-step guidance on getting out of debt, get Solve Your Money Troubles.
Contents of the Written Objection
At a minimum, your written objection to the garnishment should include the following information:
the case number and case caption (ex: “XYZ Bank vs. John Doe”)
the date of your objection
your name and current contact information
the reasons (or “grounds”) for your objection, and
Stating the Grounds for the Objection
If you believe that your earnings are exempt in full or in part under federal or state law, you should state that fact within your written objection. Explain the nature of the exemptions and provide calculations. Many states have a form specifically designed for this purpose. For more information on exemptions in wage garnishment, read Nolo's Using Exemptions to Protect Your Wages From Garnishments.
You may have additional reasons to oppose the garnishment. For example, you have already paid the judgment creditor or you received a bankruptcy discharge. In that case, you should describe the basis for that objection.
If you do not state your reasons for objecting to the garnishment and timely file that written objection with the right court, you may have waived your right to fight the garnishment later. Therefore, it is extremely important that you file a written objection as soon as possible.
The Garnishment Hearing
If the court provides for a garnishment hearing, you must attend that hearing to protect your wages. The hearing date and time is either provided automatically with the initial garnishment notice, or given to you later, after you have filed your objection. If the court has not given you a hearing date even though you timely filed an objection, you should immediately contact the clerk of that court to find out the status of your objection and hearing dates, if any.
At the hearing, you are not allowed to argue about the validity of the judgment itself. Instead, the hearing is limited to your claim of exemption or other reason why you believe the garnishment is improper.
What to bring. You should bring copies of documents that support your objection, such as recent paystubs if you are claiming an income-based exemption.
If your objection is based strictly on state or federal exemptions, the judgment creditor's attorney might not even appear unless it believes that your income is higher than what you claim. In that case, you just need to make your case with the judge or magistrate, who will interpret your claim of exemption in accordance with the available state and/or federal exemptions.
If the judge or magistrate accepts (or “sustains”) your objection, then the garnishment may be modified downward or terminated altogether. If your objection does not hold sway with the court, then it will overrule it and allow the garnishment to proceed as it was filed.
Special Garnishments: Taxes and Student Loans
Some creditors do not need to get a judgment from a court before they can legally garnish your wages. Those creditors include the IRS (and state and local tax creditors) and your student loan lender. Nonetheless, you still have some rights. You will have to follow somewhat different procedures if you wish to object to the wage garnishment, depending on who is trying to garnish you. At a minimum, you will have to submit a written objection and claim any exemptions you may have available under separate federal or state laws, usually within a short period of time after receiving notice of the garnishment.
Wage Garnishments for Taxes
If the IRS intends to garnish your wages, you should receive written notice of its intent to levy your wages. You will be given an opportunity to claim exemptions depending on your household size and income, on a form provided by the IRS. These exemptions are different than exemptions you would be entitled to take under other state and federal exemption laws. State and local taxing authorities may be able to similarly go after your wages, subject to caps on the amount they can take from your wages. You should research the laws of your state to find out more information.
Wage Garnishments for Student Loans
If you default on a student loan, you should be given at least 30 days written notice of the garnishment. This gives you an opportunity to request hardship assistance (including a new payment plan), make a written objection or or request a hearing.
To learn more, see Challenging a Student Loan Wage Garnishment.
This article provides a rough guide for what you must do to object to a wage garnishment. The types of procedures available to you depends on the laws of your state and the type of debt that is involved. To find out the specifics, you should research your state's statutes to learn more. You can also research the rules of the court that issue the garnishment, or contact the clerk of that court. Finally, you may wish to contact a local debt attorney for advice on what to do, or hire an attorney to represent you in the garnishment hearing.
To learn more about wage garnishments, see If Your Wages are Garnished: Your Rights.