Need Professional Help? Talk to a Lawyer
Enter Your Zip Code to Connect with a Lawyer Serving Your Area
Question:
Can the prosecutor back out of a plea deal?
Answer:
Sometimes, prosecutors agree to certain deals out of
court and then change their minds in front of the judge. In most places, the
defendant caught in such a situation would have the right to simply withdraw a
plea of guilty. To deter prosecutors from going back on a deal, defendants
should have the agreed-to terms put in writing before going before the judge.
If the prosecutor agrees only to make a recommendation or to not oppose the
defense lawyer’s request for a certain sentence, however, the court may refuse
to allow the defendant to withdraw the plea. See Federal Rule of Criminal
Procedure 11(e)(2); Santabello v. N.Y., U.S. Sup. Ct. 1971.
Sometimes, prosecutors agree to certain deals out of court and then change their minds in front of the judge. In most places, the defendant caught in such a situation would have the right to simply withdraw a plea of guilty. To deter prosecutors from going back on a deal, defendants should have the agreed-to terms put in writing before going before the judge. If the prosecutor agrees only to make a recommendation or to not oppose the defense lawyer’s request for a certain sentence, however, the court may refuse to allow the defendant to withdraw the plea. See Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11(e)(2); Santabello v. N.Y., U.S. Sup. Ct. 1971.
by: Paul Bergman